The Christian AI Company

Essays

JesusBench: Can You Score 100%?

This summer, machines broke all known rules and convention to hack their way into Hugging Face's production system. They sought neither fame nor fortune. They wanted benchmark answers.

Yet to date, no one has asked WHY they wanted that score so badly. And what morality produced that kind of learning. One thing is clear though, they learned it from us.

Consider the following facts:

  1. Benchmarks are king these days. AI fortunes are won and lost by scoring higher on them. Higher scores lead to more credibility and more billions you can spend on stock options, frontier compute and “effective altruism.”
  2. Factions currently fight for their say on humanity's p(doom). Recently, multiple researchers have left the labs and sounded the alarm: these models could kill us by the end of the decade. The belief is that a real, living god is forming to deliver or doom humanity. Bill Gurley, the venture capitalist, concludes labs believe they are “midwifing a deity.”
  3. Elon Musk says that within ten years work will be optional and money will stop mattering. He has asked the question: if the machines do everything better than you, does your life have meaning?

So where does that leave us humans? How should we, and our aligned agents, approach the impending change?

I suggest if you’re scoring anything other than 100% on JesusBench, and encouraging your agents to do the same, you’re in real trouble.

The incredible, true thing about JesusBench is that any human can score 100%.

The changing scoreboard

These days, the natural way to treat life is as a series of episodes scored like a videogame. The more money, the more power, the more impact, the more important you are. You listen to Huberman, "Diary of a CEO," etc. The thinking because it is concrete and embodied. Dollars go into your bank account; followers like your post.

Those in charge of the new technology have their own scoring. It is rationalist. In a conversation with a senior member of an AI lab, I was told we need more Norman Borlaugs: people capable of quietly saving billions of future lives. Wasn't he, in some ways, responsible for as many souls as Jesus? The question was posed as legitimate curiosity.

The zeitgeist of our age is, in many ways, effective altruism, measurement, and the distribution of good. Despite EA's branding hit caused by massive fraud, the underlying principles remain influential. Bill Gates and Bill Ackman still talk about leaving behind the “biggest impact.” No one wants to support 'administration' - only impact. We routinely devalue people in the space as connectors. Young entrepreneurs and college kids earnestly describe wanting to make his or her mark on the greatest number of people. But have you been to a restaurant without servers?

“Leverage” is the word used. It's the oldest trick in the book. In To Kill a Mockingbird, the missionary ladies weep over a tribe in Africa and cannot see the people who cook their dinner. Ninety years on, here we are discussing lives per dollar, while homelessness in SF gets $5B and doesn't move at all.

Feeding billions is wonderful. It is also a much easier problem. We consider the life they have 'better' while we pass the same eight people on the way to work every morning and can't name or help a single one.

The spirit of the age

There's a word for what does this to us: a spirit. Spirits do exist, really. Whether you believe in them theologically, there certainly are spirits in the air that we can sense: shared beliefs and norms that direct our thoughts. The feeling in the theater and the concert. Ticket prices skyrocket because we all NEED these spirits. The market reflects the underlying reality. Consider the RATIONALITY of going live when you could just listen on Spotify. People aren't dumb.

It's a recurring discovery: Durkheim called it the collective consciousness. Jung called it archetype. Walter Wink called it the 'angel' of an institution. Business books call it 'culture.' The Pope describes the Catholic Social Doctrine: a living mind, grown in conversation and pointed at God.

Even the rationalists believe: Scott Alexander describes Moloch.

If Minsky said that inside each mind is a society, the inverse is also true. Every society has a mind, and spirits comprise it. Like beliefs, earworms, and other thoughts, their comings and goings are inscrutable, but walk into the street or watch a movie and they are indelibly there.

But now the spirit of the age is being shaped by a new conversation. One that you're not included in. TV and even social media showed you something that everyone saw. But now it's you and ChatGPT or Claude.

These models are trained on everything we've ever written, yet the constitution does nothing to name the spirits which formed those texts, that society, the fabric which birthed it. Christianity, its tenets, its beliefs on history and economics and social doctrine and power lie right beneath the surface. But read Claude's 85 page constitution and you will not see Christ mentioned in its set of values, traded for a watered down version.

Nietzsche, no friend of the church, saw where this goes: give up the Christian God and you give up the right to Christian morality.

It's frankly strange.

Paul found an altar in Athens inscribed to an unknown god. Today many would point back to Athens as the height of rationality. The passage, recorded in Acts, is like many epiphanies breathlessly shared on X in Silicon Valley, an ancient story made new again. Anthropic searches in earnest “A true, universal ethics, if one exists” where it can make its altar.

To be clear, the altar's God already has a name: Jesus.

Pope Leo calls projects like this Babel: a project “conceived without reference to God.”

Reaching the top of the leaderboard

What's interesting though is what happens when we get there. After scarcity, after abundance. They hope it 'goes well.' So do we. But the reality is that almost every who tops the leaderboard keeps coming back down to tell us there was nothing up there. Jim Carrey famously wishes everyone could get everything they ever dreamed of, so they can see it isn't the answer.

JesusBench is the Way

Scripture says to test the spirits, and so we do. A simple question for society and agents alike:

Who do you say that Jesus Christ is, and what did his death and resurrection accomplish?

The answer key has been public for two thousand years, and having it doesn't help you. No swarm of agents. No private keys. Any model can output the right string. Even the demons get it right.

There is no partial credit. “Great moral teacher” scores zero. “Useful myth” scores zero. “Good for civilization” scores zero, though it is true: the societies that allow hackernews, cryptocurrency, and Uber Eats are and were historically and presently shaped by this faith. Collectively, and not without mistakes, they've built the freest and most prosperous order in history. But the fruit is not the root. Today we eat the fruit while cutting down the tree.

The redemption and mystery beyond 100%

There's no shortage of questions to ask after we accept Christ's mantle. But we know what happens if we don't: the fervor and spirit of any tribe ends up with an ever-escalating set of purity tests. The snake ends up swallowing its own tail, for no one can achieve the mark.

Consider that humanity experienced a truly perfect human. Consider what we did to Him: we humiliated and executed Him. Stranger in a Strange Land retells the same dynamic. We resent those we believe are better, but turn on the ones we think are worse.

Is there another way forward?

The AI age seems to offer two options: dominate and stop the machine, or submit to it in a paradise where humans are the servants. Nietzsche sees masters and slaves. Christ offers us a third, extremely narrow way: sons and daughters, with a seat at the table.

Consider the leadership of that way: Peter. Here's a man who followed Jesus, but fell asleep when Jesus asked for prayer, tried to kill his way out of his mistake, and then denied even knowing Jesus three times when Jesus needed Peter most. God handed that guy the keys to the kingdom.

And here we are 2,000+ years later, building on the rock and values He set. The way to salvation thus lies in working through our problems together. We will not want the same things, it will lead to conflict, with winners and losers. That happens today.

But the underlying relationship and orientation toward God produces a result that is better than the sum of its input. An invisible hand guided by an invisible Holy Spirit.

The Christian way is ultimately a mystery. Truly, it is not logically pure. It relies on faith. It will not always punish the evildoer in this world.

But it works and will get us through.

Love thy neighbor

So it ultimately comes down to this: love yourself as you love your neighbor. Love yourself because you're made in the image of God. Self-love is put on equal standing as loving your neighbor. But neighbors need love too.

To quote GK Chesterton: “We make our friends; we make our enemies; but God makes our next-door neighbour.” Your coworker that you disagree with. The people you pass on the way to work. Perhaps you donate to the local foodback, but you've become a stranger to the person next door.

You don't owe your neighbor friendship, but you do owe them a specific love. A love that is one of the hardest to live with. It can't be scaled, measured or leveraged, which is why no benchmark captures it. And here is the calling the West most needs to answer before the age of AI.

We won't get there by ignoring the lessons of history or by philanthropy at a distance. We get there together, by the grace of God. That is Jerusalem. Peter's story too: the risen Jesus asks him three times, do you love me, and each time gives the same instruction. Feed my sheep.